Kolkata’s Chorbagan Puja Pandal Stampede

            One’s heart aches to learn of stampede tragedies like the one at Kolkata’s Chorbagan Durga Puja pandal today. Condolences to the kin of those who suffered in the tragedy.

            For a long time we have been an overpopulated country, bursting at the seams and struggling to provide fair means of dignified survival for all. It was no secret even several decades ago that we were heading towards becoming the most populous country in the world, and new dynamic measures would have to be devised for handling the large numbers in several areas of our lives.

            Urgent measures should have been initiated from the “Hum Do Hamare Do” days itself, employing the most practical minds our authorities could call upon.  But it wasn’t done.  A strong slogan was coined and thought sufficient. Evidently, it wasn’t. There have been many stampede deaths in India in these prevailing years. Short term noises are made and the short public memory ensures that the stories get buried and forgotten soon.

            These were just simple, common people out to celebrate Durga Puja, in family groups perhaps, and pay obeisance at the pandals. The elders might have been narrating anecdotes and educating the youngsters on the richness of our culture. There was, naturally, the least suspicion of the unprecedented horror awaiting them that evening.

            The fact is that Indian common people are mostly simple, religious, and family oriented, and deserve well thought out SOPs to handle crowds for smooth conduct of celebrations and festivities, with proper dignified methods other than wielding batons willy-nilly.

            We can start making the effort even now.

            We have had genius minds creating the postal pin code system, the metro rail systems, the adhaar card, and many more creations that changed for the better the way the country functioned. There is no reason why we cannot do it in this matter too. The lack of initiative seems to indicate that this matter is not considered urgent and real. Or must we resign ourselves to the easier way out that seems to have been preferred – of simply creating two broad categories of citizens – ‘them’, and ‘us’.

            ‘Us’ would evidently be the entitled classes, who have first rights on anything important, enriching, and preferential. They have the authority to frame the rules that govern the nation. So then, ‘them’ would imaginably consist of the common people, those unimportant but essential elements of society who are but useful to ensure an unending supply of taxes for the nation’s coffers. For any other important purpose, they are best ignored, forgotten, chased away, wished away, kept away from the mind, for they remind the authorized classes of their duties and responsibilities, which ‘is quite a burden’.

            That is not a pretty picture we paint of ourselves before the world. It’s high time serious due thought was given to the matter.
                                                                            *****

#KolkataStampede #DurgaPuja #CrowdManagement #PublicSafety #DisasterPrevention #SafetyOfCitizens #ChorbaganPujaPandalStampede

6 Comments

  1. Manoj Nathani

    blaming the cops isn’t a solution , how can a handful of cops handle a crowd of few 1000s ?
    let’s work to improve crowd management , say ,15-20sec / person inside the pandal

    • Sanjay

      Thank you for the feedback.
      There is no cop-blaming in the article. Just suggested we have in place SOPs for crowd management of our extraordinary numbers, which are now long overdue.

  2. spondon ganguli

    Well said. I completely agree with you.
    One more thing i would like to add here is, basic discipline and I should not be the first lacks in us.
    I need to be the first, i need the first rank, i need the first seat, i need the first plate..this creates unnecessary rush and thus more problem and accidents.
    I recently visited Aizawl city. People are disciplined and follow the line. No rush on road, no road accident. Crowd is there but no stampede.

    • Sanjay

      Yes, Spondon. You’ve hit the nail on the head – the rush to be the first to do or be something. And in hordes. Obviously then, the flow will be choked. If only we realised.

  3. Shashi

    This has become a routine affair in India with poor people “Stamped in religious congregation”
    They stepped out as families, bound by faith and the simple joy of celebration, passing down heritage to the next generation. They expected the warmth of the pandals, not the cold shadow of tragedy. We honor their innocent memory and stand in quiet grief with those whose lives were forever changed that evening.”
    Sad state of affairs

    • Sanjay

      Very well expressed, Shashi. You virtually spoke my mind.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *